Muffins & Crumpets (Mrs. Beeton's)
Submitted by Spud
Mrs. Beeton’s Victorian English muffins and crumpets made with mashed potato in the yeast dough. Authentic 1860s recipe for proper griddle-cooked English breads.
YIELD
24 servingsPREP
10 minCOOK
30 minREADY
2 hrsMrs. Beeton’s English muffins and crumpets from the legendary 1861 Book of Household Management, the recipe that defined proper British baking for a century. The single base dough produces both forms depending on how much flour you add, a brilliant Victorian efficiency.
Boiled mashed potato in the dough is the secret ingredient that distinguishes these from modern English muffins. The starch contributes moisture and a tender, slightly spongy crumb that holds up to toasting and butter without going dry. Most modern recipes skip the potato entirely, which is a loss.
For muffins, the dough is firm enough to shape into rounds and proof on a tray. For crumpets, only half the flour goes in, leaving a batter loose enough to pour into greased rings on a hot griddle. Same base, two completely different breads.
The traditional toasting method matters. Pulling the muffin apart at the edges before toasting (instead of slicing) creates the rough, craggy interior that catches butter in every nook. A clean knife cut destroys that texture entirely.
Pro Tips
Use floury potatoes like russets for the dough. Waxy potatoes don’t break down properly and leave lumps.
The potato water (the cooking liquid) should be lukewarm, not hot. Hot water kills the yeast on contact.
Use a heavy cast iron griddle if you have one. Even heat distribution is essential for properly cooked muffins and crumpets.
Don’t slice the toasted muffins with a knife. Pulling them apart with fingers creates that signature craggy interior that holds butter.
Variations
Add a tablespoon of milk powder to the muffin dough for richer flavor and softer crumb.
Knead in a handful of currants or raisins for traditional Victorian English currant muffins.
Use whole wheat flour for half the white flour for a heartier, more rustic version.
Ingredients
Directions
MUFFINS:
Wash, peel and boil the potatoes, rub through a colander, add the water (just warm enough to bear the hand in it without discomfort); then dissolve the yeast and salt in it, and stir in sufficient flour to make a moist paste.
Beat it well in a deep bowl and then clear off the paste from the hands; cover over with a clean cloth and leave it to rise in a warm place.
When it has well risen, and is light and spongy, turn it out on the table, dredge over with flour, and then divide it off into pieces about 3 oz in weight, roll them up into round shapes, and set them on a wooden tray, well dusted with flour to proof.
When light enough, see that the hot plate is hot, and then carefully transfer the muffins from the tray, one at a time, using a thin tin slice for the purpose, taking particular care not to knock out the proof or the muffins will be spoilt.
When they have been properly cooked on one side, turn over with the slice and cook the other side.
When the muffins are done, brush off the flour, and lay them on a clean clothe or sieve to cool.
To toast them, divide the edge of the muffin all round by pulling it open to the depth of about 1 inch with the fingers.
Put it on a toasting fork and hold it before a clear fire until one side is nicely browned, but not burnt; turn, and toast it on the other.
Do not toast them too quickly, otherwise the middle of the muffin will not be warmed through.
When done, divide them by pulling them open; butter them slighlty on both sides, put them together again, and cut them into halves.
Pile on a hot dish and send quickly to table.
CRUMPETS:
Proceed exactly the same as directed for Muffins (above), but stir in only half the quantity of flour used for them, so that the mixture is more of a batter than a sponge. Cover over, and leave for ½ an hour.
At the end of that time take a large wooden spoon and well beat up the batter, leave in the spoon, cover over, and leave for another ½ an hour. Then give the batter another good beat up. This process must be repeated 3 times with the intervals.
When completed, see that the hot plate is quite hot, lay out some crumpet rings rubbed over inside with a little clean lard on a baking tin, and pour in sufficient of the batter to make the crumpets.
When cooked on one side, turn over with a palette-knife, and when done take off on to a clean cloth to cool.
Muffins and crumpets should always be served on separate dishes, and both toasted and served as quickly as possible. Make 24 muffins or crumpets.
Comments
